PWInsider - WWE News, Wrestling News, WWE

 
 

Rethinking Mail-Order Brides: A Two-Year Psychological Study by Dr. Peggy Bolcoa

By Dr. Peggy Bolcoa on 2025-08-21 09:28:00

Rethinking Mail-Order Brides: Insights from a Two-Year Psychological Study

Hey friends, I’m Peggy Bolcoa, licensed psychotherapist with over 20 years of experience specializing in relationships, marriage counseling, and cross-cultural couples. If you’ve ever heard the term mail order brides, you’ve probably got an image in your head—maybe from TV, tabloids, or old stereotypes. But what if I told you those images are mostly wrong?

Over the last two years, I dedicated myself to an in-depth study of this phenomenon: “The Phenomenon of Mail Order Brides in Today’s U.S. Society”. This research combines my clinical work with couples, my own interviews, and analysis of international studies and statistics. What I learned turned my own assumptions upside down.

This isn’t about “buying a bride.” It’s about love, culture, hope, and yes—sometimes desperation. It’s also about how the internet revolutionized intimacy in ways nobody predicted.

So let’s take a real look at this phenomenon, with no sugarcoating and no judgment.

A Little Backstory: Where Did the Term Even Come From?

Before we get into today’s world, it helps to know where the phrase mail order bride started.

  • 19th Century America: Settlers on the frontier often lived in towns with 50 men for every woman. Men advertised in newspapers, women wrote back, and marriages were made—by letter.

  • Post-War Marriages: After WWII and the Vietnam War, thousands of American soldiers married women from Japan, Korea, the Philippines, and Vietnam. Many of these marriages were long-lasting and stable.

  • 1990s Internet Boom: Matchmaking agencies went digital. Suddenly, a guy in Kansas could connect with a woman in Ukraine with a few clicks.

What was once literally “mail order” has transformed into highly interactive, global online matchmaking.

Who Are These Women, Really?

Let’s bust the first big myth: these women aren’t desperate “runaways” or naïve girls. In my study, they fell into several clear groups. So, let's take a look at what “mail order bride meaning” is in practice.

1. The Professionals

Educated, working, and career-focused—but feeling limited by opportunities at home.

  • Case Study: Elena (Ukraine) – English teacher, 29, said: “I wanted a family and a partner who supported me, not just another survival game.”

  • Case Study: Maricel (Philippines) – A nurse who wanted to work in the U.S. to support her parents back home.

2. The Single Mothers

Many came from cultures where single moms faced stigma and limited dating pools.

  • Case Study: Sofia (Colombia) – Mother of two. She told me, “In my city, men avoid women with kids. In the U.S., he loved that I was already a mom.”

3. The Adventurers

Women who craved cultural exchange, new languages, new countries.

  • Case Study: Alina (Russia) – Loved travel blogs, signed up on a site out of curiosity. Married a French-American artist.

4. The Stability Seekers

Women from unstable economies who wanted security for themselves and their future children.

These weren’t victims. They were women making bold, strategic, and deeply personal choices.

Why Men Are So Interested in Foreign Women

This was the biggest question my male interviewees wanted to justify. Their reasons weren’t simple, but patterns emerged.

1. “Traditional Values” (or what they imagined them to be)

Many men said they felt U.S. dating had become transactional or career-first, and they wanted a more family-first partner.

2. Age Flexibility

Men in their 40s and 50s often felt ignored in U.S. dating. They reported that women abroad were more open to age gaps.

3. Emotional Freshness

Divorced men especially said, “She didn’t treat me like I was broken.”

4. Adventure Factor

Dating abroad felt bold. Many men admitted it just made them feel alive again.

5. Gender Scripts

Men perceived that women abroad valued masculine roles (provider, protector) more.

6. Burnout With Apps

Men tired of swiping on Tinder or Bumble turned to international platforms.

7. Sense of Importance

Men said international women paid attention in ways they hadn’t felt in years.

8. Religious & Cultural Values

Some actively sought women from similar religious backgrounds but different cultures.

9. Family Orientation

Many men believed international women placed children and marriage higher on their priorities.

10. Idealization of “Femininity”

This was psychological—men admitted they had fantasies about how “feminine” or “romantic” women from certain cultures were.

Case Studies: Real Couples, Real Stories

Tom & Mai (U.S. + Vietnam)

Tom, 47, twice divorced, said: “In America I felt like damaged goods. Mai treated me like a man with potential.” Married 7 years now.

Carlos & Ana (U.S. + Mexico)

Ana was studying accounting when she met Carlos online. Their shared Catholic faith bonded them. They’re raising three kids today.

Robert & Yulia (U.S. + Russia)

Robert, a quiet engineer, admitted, “I was invisible in bars. Yulia actually saw me.” Married 10 years.

Greg & Maria (U.S. + Philippines)

Greg, retired military, wanted stability. Maria wanted security for her kids. They found both in each other.

Ethan & Lila (U.S. + Colombia)

Ethan, 29, said: “Everyone thinks this is just for older guys. But I met my wife because I wanted something serious.”

How Mail Order Bride Sites Changed the Game

The old “catalog” image is dead. What exists now are platforms that function like global dating apps—only with more serious intentions.

The Tech Shift

  • Video calls: Cuts through scams.

  • AI translation: Makes conversation possible in seconds.

  • Profile filters: Lets people match based on values, not just looks.

Why They Work Better (Sometimes) Than Tinder

  • People come in with marriage in mind, not hookups.

  • Communication feels more formal and intentional.

  • Stigma has faded—people openly say “we met on an international site.”

Market Reality

Billions of dollars now flow through international matchmaking sites. Whether you love it or hate it, it’s not going away.

The Myths We Need to Kill

Before we go myth-busting, let me say this: the word mail order bride is already a myth in itself. Nobody is mailing anyone. These are women making conscious choices. Yet, over decades, stereotypes have piled up—shaped by movies, media scandals, and gossip. They stick because they’re juicy, but they’re lazy.

In my study, I heard couples laugh at these ideas, sometimes cry about them, and often just shrug them off. But myths have consequences: they shape how families react, how society judges, and even how couples see themselves. So let’s pull them out into the light and show why they don’t hold up.

Myth #1: The Women Are “Bought”

No—they pick and choose as much as the men do. In fact, rejection rates from women were higher than from men on most sites.

Myth #2: Men Want Submissive Partners

Most men wanted romance and companionship, not servants. The word “partnership” came up constantly in interviews.

Myth #3: It’s About Green Cards

Sure, immigration is part of it—but many women left comfortable lives behind. For some, visas were the hardest part of the relationship.

Myth #4: Only Old Men Do This

I saw men in their 20s through their 70s. Age diversity was wider than you’d expect.

Myth #5: High Divorce Rates

In my sample, these marriages had slightly lower divorce rates than domestic marriages. Commitment levels were high because couples worked so hard to get together in the first place.

Myth #6: It’s Just Sex Tourism

The couples I interviewed weren’t chasing flings. They were building families, buying homes, planning futures.

Myth #7: Women Are Forced

Agency was central. These women weren’t “sent” anywhere—they were making decisions.

Myth #8: It’s Dangerous and Abusive by Default

Abuse can happen in any marriage. To paint all international marriages this way is unfair and harmful.

What Psychology Says About All This

Here’s the part I love the most: the psychology. When you strip away the headlines, what you see are people acting out deep emotional needs, attachment styles, and survival instincts. International marriages exaggerate these dynamics, because you’ve got culture, language, and distance adding extra pressure. Let me break down what stood out most in my two-year study.

  • Attachment Styles: Avoidant men sought new contexts to try intimacy.

  • Fantasy Meets Reality: Cultural stereotypes fueled attraction but needed adjusting once couples lived together.

  • Balance of Power: Couples had to constantly negotiate who “led” and who “adapted.”

  • Identity Struggles: Women often wrestled with missing home culture while trying to fit into a new one.

8 Reasons Women Said “Yes” to International Marriage

Before anyone assumes it’s “all about money,” let me be clear: the women I met were motivated by many different things. Sure, economic stability played a role for some—but it was rarely the whole story. Love, adventure, family, and even simple curiosity were just as powerful. Here are the most common reasons they said yes.

  1. Better opportunities for kids

  2. Escape from stigma (single motherhood, divorce)

  3. Economic stability

  4. Desire for men who commit

  5. Adventure and travel

  6. Broader dating pool

  7. Religious compatibility

  8. Curiosity and open-mindedness

8 Challenges Couples Faced

Now, don’t get me wrong—it’s not all smooth sailing. These couples faced obstacles that most domestic couples never deal with. Immigration law, culture shock, language stress, and family expectations can put a marriage through fire. The good news? The couples who survived told me the hardships made them stronger.

  1. Visa struggles

  2. Language barriers

  3. Homesickness

  4. Power imbalance fears

  5. Family disapproval

  6. Raising kids biculturally

  7. Career sacrifices

  8. Cultural miscommunication

Red Flags I Saw in Practice

Not every story was rosy. As a therapist, I noticed patterns that often signaled trouble down the road. These weren’t always dealbreakers, but when left unchecked, they grew into major problems. If you’re thinking of international marriage—or supporting someone who is—keep an eye out for these warning signs.

  • One partner demanding all financial control

  • Unrealistic expectations about age gaps

  • Couples who never visited each other in person before marriage

  • Men who saw women as “saviors” for loneliness

  • Women who expected instant financial luxury

Voices That Stay With Me

“I wasn’t buying a bride. I was buying a chance at happiness.” — Mark, 52

“People assume I wanted a visa. But I had security back home. I chose love, not paperwork.” — Svetlana, 34

“The first year was brutal—new country, new language. But we made it, and it’s the best decision I ever made.” — Ana, 31

Final Thoughts

After two years of research, interviews, and therapy sessions, here’s what I know: international marriages are real marriages. They come with quirks, challenges, and beauty. They aren’t “mail order.” They’re love stories that happen to cross borders.

Do some end badly? Sure. But many grow into deep, resilient partnerships.

If we stop stereotyping and start listening, we might just understand that love looks different around the world—but at its core, it’s always the same: two people trying to build something together.

About the Author

Dr. Peggy Bolcoa is a licensed psychotherapist with over 20 years of experience specializing in relationships, marriage counseling, and cross-cultural couples. She combines compassionate guidance with evidence-based insights, helping individuals and partners build stronger, healthier connections across emotional and cultural boundaries.

If you enjoy PWInsider.com you can check out the AD-FREE PWInsider Elite section, which features exclusive audio updates, news, our critically acclaimed podcasts, interviews and more by clicking here!