PWInsider - WWE News, Wrestling News, WWE

CAN I SUE THE TRUCKING COMPANY IF I WAS DRIVING THEIR TRUCK AT THE TIME OF AN ACCIDENT?

You may be wondering if you can pursue legal action against the trucking company that employs you if you were driving one of their trucks when an accident occurred. This is a complex area of law with many nuances to consider on a case-by-case basis. 

Here is what you should know.

Overview

The legal doctrine that generally governs who is liable in truck accidents where the driver is an employee is known as "respondeat superior." This Latin term means "let the superior make answer." It allows for employers or principals to be held legally responsible for the negligent acts of their employees or agents.

Some key principles of respondeat superior liability to keep in mind:

• Employers can be considered liable for employee actions that occur within the course and scope of employment

• Course and scope is determined by factors like whether the activity aligned with job duties

• Employers are not liable for intentional criminal acts or gross negligence

• Employees can also be held personally liable depending on the case specifics

So in your situation, the key question becomes: were your actions leading up to the accident within the course and scope of your job duties as a truck driver for the company?

Assessing If the Accident Occurred Within the Course and Scope of Employment

To determine if the trucking company can be held vicariously liable based on respondeat superior, several factors would be analyzed:

What counts as within course and scope?

• Following assigned routes and making required deliveries

• Operating the vehicle in alignment with company safety policies and procedures

• Actions that further the employer's business purposes

What typically falls outside course and scope?

• Intentionally illegal activity (assault, theft, etc.)

• Reckless activity in defiance of policies (extreme speeding)

• Actions serving purely personal interests

The specific details of what transpired leading up to your accident would be thoroughly reviewed under this framework.

If there is room for reasonable debate regarding whether you were acting within the course and scope of work duties, your case would be more likely to move forward. The trucking company may still raise defenses arguing their non-liability even so.

Determining If the Trucking Company Was Negligent

In addition to course and scope considerations, courts require evidence that the trucking company itself acted negligently in a way that caused or contributed to the accident for liability to attach. Typically, this usually necessitates proving the 5 elements of negligence.

Common negligent actions by trucking firms that can make it easy for you to prove negligence on their part can include:

• Failure to properly maintain vehicles

• Inadequate driver training and supervision

• Violations of federal safety regulations

• Pressuring drivers to meet unrealistic delivery windows

• Condoning a culture that encourages unsafe driving

Your attorney would conduct an in-depth investigation into the trucking company's safety record, policies, and actions to build arguments regarding their negligence.

If little evidence of negligence exists, you'd have a weaker basis to hold them legally accountable. The degree of negligence could also impact the percentage of fault and damages allocated.

Special Workers Comp Considerations

Importantly, if you were a direct employee of the trucking company at the time of the accident, then workers' compensation laws also come into play. In most states, this would provide medical and wage benefits regardless of fault.

However, workers comp is usually the exclusive remedy meaning you forfeit the right to separately sue your employer. This might be disadvantageous, especially for someone suffering long term injuries as the compensation provided under workers’ compensation laws may not be sufficient to cover all future medical costs.

There are limited exceptions though. One such exception is proven intentional injury. But workers comp disputes would need to enter administrative proceedings rather than a civil lawsuit.

If you were an independent contractor or temporary driver, then workers comp may not apply, and a liability lawsuit remains possible. The exact employment relationship factors significantly into the viable legal avenues.

Building Your Case Through Evidence and Testimony

If your situation indicates reasonable grounds for a respondeat superior claim against the motor carrier, gathering compelling evidence and testimony to prove negligence becomes paramount. 

Key forms of proof your attorney may use include:

• Accident reconstruction analysis

• The truck's electronic data and maintenance records

• Federal/state regulatory violations

• Background check and credentials for the driver

• Eyewitness statements

• Police reports

• Photographic evidence from the scene

• Records related to company policies, training, compensation rules, delivery time pressures, and more

Eyewitnesses, expert testimony, and other evidence would seek to demonstrate identifiable actions by the company that breached the duty to provide properly qualified drivers, safe equipment, adequate routes, realistic delivery expectations, and adherence to federal regulations.

Presenting a clear theory regarding what specifically the company did wrong leading to the preventable incident strengthens the case and argument for damages.

Typical Defenses Raised by Trucking Companies

When sued, trucking companies have some common counterarguments they tend to employ. Understanding potential defenses helps assess case viability. Frequent claims raised include:

• The driver acted outside the course and scope of work duties

• An intervening criminal act by a third party was the cause

• Government regulations constrain delivery windows and options

• The plaintiff's own negligence contributed to the accident

• Lack of evidence proving the company's direct role in the cause

Respondeat superior cases often boil down to a debate regarding whether the employer's business interests directly motivated the negligent action. The trucking firm will try shifting blame entirely back onto the driver's personal choices and conduct.

Overcoming these defenses requires building a compelling claim the company's policies, unreasonable expectations, negligence, or recklessness foreseeably precipitated the sequence of events -- despite the driver being the immediate cause.

Calculating the Potential Value of Damages

If successful in court, the possible out-of-court legal settlement or award amount depends primarily upon the:

• Medical bills stemming from any injuries

• Lost income and reduced future earnings

• Loss of enjoyment/quality of life

• Pain and suffering

Punitive damages may also be warranted if gross negligence involving willful indifference to safety can be established.

Damages tie directly to demonstrable losses and harm. Building the highest provable dollar value associated with all short and long-term accident impacts strengthens your position. Thoroughly documenting financial costs, emotional distress, permanent disability/disfigurement, and other hardships provides justification for maximizing the potential settlement or court award.

Contributory Negligence Can Reduce Award Amounts

One other vital consideration is how comparative negligence or contributory negligence laws in the state where the accident happened could affect damage amounts owed.

In some states, even just 1% of fault assigned to you, the plaintiff, diminishes the claim value and reduces payouts proportionally. Other states only apply this rule if the plaintiff was 51%+ at fault.

Trucking companies routinely try assigning partial blame to the driver as a defense tactic in liability disputes. Working with an experienced attorney helps overcome such arguments and fights to minimize any negligence attributed to your role, which protects full compensation.

Steps to Take After a Truck Accident

To have a strong shot at winning damages from the trucking company through a lawsuit, promptly taking certain post-accident steps bolsters the prospects:

1. Report the crash to the police to get an official report documenting vital evidence

2. Seek medical help right away even for minor symptoms to have injuries on record

3. Take photos and video of property damage, injuries, skid marks, and overall scene

4. Obtain contact info for witnesses especially if supporting your version of events

5. Do not make statements accepting fault or admitting guilt to anyone

6. Retain an attorney experienced with truck accident claims for guidance in navigating legal issues

Following these best practices from the outset facilitates building leverage in liability disputes and fights for maximum restitution down the line.

Final Thoughts

At the end of the day, being able to successfully take legal action against a trucking company while driving their truck requires an in-depth analysis of the accident circumstances, employment details, applicable regulations, and state laws, and making strategic arguments regarding negligence and vicarious liability under respondeat superior.

An attorney experienced in this highly technical field can thoroughly investigate the situation, identify viable angles to pursue or dismiss the case if unsupported, and then aggressively litigate on your behalf if demonstrating evidence and legal grounds to hold the motor carrier responsible for any losses. Without clear proof, the company will likely escape liability shifting it solely onto the driver. Documentation is key from day one.

 

If you enjoy PWInsider.com you can check out the AD-FREE PWInsider Elite section, which features exclusive audio updates, news, our critically acclaimed podcasts, interviews and more by clicking here!

• Tweet